The search for truth begins with the knowledge of ones own
ignorance. As Socrates would argue, it is in knowing what it is that we do
know, and subsequently what it is that we do not know. This was likewise a
theme of Confucius in the Great learning. The question is asked, what does it
mean to be a great ruler? Through a lengthy chain it leads ultimately to the
understanding of things, which leads back to the beginning, the goal of being a
great leader.
So it is, from completely foreign perspectives, we find the
same themes originating at separate places across the world. These would
continue to perplex mankind throughout history. A desire for knowledge, for
understanding, and the challenge that this presents.
It was Hume who would ultimately present the paradox. That
our knowledge of the world is derived from experience. From a process of
induction through enumeration, we can arrive to a general understanding,
however there is nothing in our experience that can affirm with certainty that
this would be so. Hence we must conclude that there is no knowledge that is
certainty.
Thus defined, we are left with one of two conclusions. That
there is truth, or that we live in a universe without truth. The latter is
completely non sensical, so in order to have any understanding, we must start
with the assumption that there is truth. This ultimately leads us back to the
conclusion of Descartes, and the principle of Cartesian doubt. Cognito Ergo
Suma, I think therefore I am.
This leads Kant to his conclusion in the Critique of pure
reason. That while it is impossible to know a thing in and of itself, we are
predisposed to reason. For instance, if one were to draw two parallel lines, they
would have to be at precisely the same angle, or they would eventually
intersect. To know for certain, we would have to draw an infinite number of
lines, yet that would be impossible. We just know this to be true, because we
are predisposed to being rational beings.
While Kant solved the problem of Hume, it was purchased at a
price. That is why he is called the great destroyer. We can never know the
thing in and of itself, only the perception of being. So while we can know that
there is truth, that there is a universe outside our perception, that it acts in
accordance to the laws of nature, we can only know our perception of this
universe, and not truth in and of itself.
No comments:
Post a Comment